Differences Between Accounting, Bookkeeping And Auditing

Close-up of a vintage handwritten ledger detailing financial records and accounts.

Are you wondering about the difference between accounting, bookkeeping, and auditing? Although these functions are closely related, they involve different responsibilities. Understanding how they differ can help you determine which service your business needs. Here are five key differences explained –

1. Differences in Accounting, Bookkeeping and Auditing Work

Bookkeeping, accounting and auditing involve different types of financial work. Bookkeeping includes maintaining financial records, while accounting may involve preparing financial statements and recording adjustment entries.

Auditing and review engagements are different because they involve specific procedures performed by a CPA to provide a level of assurance and issue a report. An auditor or reviewer must also maintain the required independence from the client.

If your business needs bookkeeping, write-up or financial statement preparation involving adjustment entries, you may need an accounting CPA rather than the CPA performing your audit or review.

Certified Public Accountants (CPAs) play a vital role in ensuring financial transparency, accuracy, and compliance for businesses and individuals. Among their various services, attestation engagements—such as audits, reviews, and examinations – are highly regulated and require strict adherence to professional standards. A common question among clients and some CPAs in Texas themselves is whether a CPA who performs attestation services can also undertake bookkeeping or general accounting work for the same client. The short answer is: generally, CPAs who perform attestation services should not perform bookkeeping or routine accounting work for the same client.

2. Accounting and Auditing: Regulatory and Ethical Requirements

The distinction between accounting and auditing is particularly important when considering CPA independence and professional ethics.

The American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA) emphasises that CPAs must maintain independence, both in appearance and in fact, when providing attest services.

When a CPA performs day-to-day bookkeeping or accounting work for a client, a potential conflict of interest may arise. This is especially important when the same CPA is also responsible for auditing or reviewing the financial statements.

Under the AICPA’s Code of Professional Conduct, certain non-attest services can affect a CPA’s independence. For example, preparing financial statements that the same CPA later audits or reviews may create concerns about objectivity.

3. Why Accounting and Auditing Services Should Be Separated

Maintaining a clear separation between bookkeeping, accounting and auditing helps protect the credibility and objectivity of an audit or review engagement.

Bookkeeping and accounting involve preparing and maintaining financial records. If the same CPA is involved in preparing those records and subsequently auditing or reviewing them, their independence may be affected.

For example, when a CPA performs bookkeeping for a client, they may also become involved in preparing the financial information that is later subject to an audit or review. Depending on the circumstances and applicable independence requirements, safeguards may be necessary. These can include engaging a different CPA or firm to perform the attest service.

4. Choosing Between Accounting and Auditing Services

Many firms have policies that restrict CPAs from performing both bookkeeping or accounting work and attest services for the same client when doing so could affect independence.

For businesses, understanding the difference between accounting and auditing helps clarify which professional services they need. If a client requires bookkeeping or accounting assistance, the CPA may recommend assigning the work to different staff, another CPA or a separate firm to maintain the independence of the audit or review engagement.

This separation helps protect the reliability of financial statements and the credibility of the reports issued.

5. Exceptions to the Separation of Accounting and Auditing Services

Although CPAs generally need to maintain a separation between bookkeeping or accounting work and attest services, certain non-attest services may be permitted under specific circumstances.

Applicable professional standards may allow these services when the required safeguards are in place. These circumstances may involve appropriate documentation, supervision and independent personnel. CPAs must evaluate the applicable independence requirements before undertaking both types of work for the same client.

Conclusion

Bookkeeping, accounting and auditing serve different purposes, but each plays a role in financial reporting. Understanding the differences between these services can help businesses identify the accounting support they need and understand why CPA independence matters during an audit or review engagement.

If you need help with financial statement compilation or preparation, learn more about our Financial Statements Compilation and Preparation services, or contact Metwally CPA to discuss your requirements.

Frequently Asked Questions

FHA requires mortgage lenders to submit audited financial statements and meet HUD compliance requirements. Maintaining the required documentation and fulfilling the audit requirements allows you to continue offering FHA lending services.

Lenders must submit audited financial statements for their previous fiscal year end.

For FHA lenders operating for less than a year, the submitted financial statements must cover operations through the current operating month.

Liquid assets should not be less than 20% of the required adjusted net worth. Lenders must also maintain adequate adjusted net worth per HUD requirements.

Non-supervised institutions must derive at least 50% of their activities from real estate mortgages, consumer installments or a similar credit advance.

If the end date of your audited financial statements is more than six months old, you must also submit unaudited financial statements signed by a corporate officer.

FHA lenders submit their recertification application through the Lender Electronic Assessment Portal (LEAP).

The recertification application must be submitted within 90 days of the fiscal year end. For a December 31 year-end, the deadline is March 31.

Lenders must submit their financial statements, complete the online certification and pay the recertification fees.

Metwally CPA PLLC conducts financial statement audits and reviews for FHA license renewal. Our founder, Mohamed Metwally, CPA, has over 15 years of audit experience and specializes in the financial services sector. Contact us to get started with your FHA audit.

Mohamed Metwally, CPA

Mohamed founded Metwally CPA PLLC in 2020 in the Dallas-Fort Worth metropolitan area. He holds active CPA license in the state of Texas and California. Mohamed is the firm’s Executive Director. Mohamed has a Master of Science (M.S.) degree in Accounting from University of Dallas. He has extensive assurance experience in a wide variety of industries, and he also devotes considerable time consulting and working with organizations and CPA firms on internal controls, audit quality, automation, and accounting best practices. He has over 15 years of audit experience.

Prior to founding the firm, Mohamed worked for big 4 and national firms for over than 10 years in the assurance practice. Mohamed worked on private clients as well as public clients and specialized in financial services sector.

He is a member of the Texas CPA Practice Issues, Diversity and Inclusion, and Governmental Accounting and Single Audits Conference Committees of Texas Society of CPAs.

Mohamed is a member of the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants, member of the AICPA small business group, member of the American institute of Certified Management Accountants, and Texas Society of Certified Public Accountants.

Share:

More Posts

Send Us A Message